Quote:
Originally Posted by tmd
Nix, as I could not agree with this more I have a question for you which you ca refrain from answering if it's too personal; you are part of a large and successfull dojo if I have understood your posts correctly how many do you find yourselves holding back and what is the drop out rate?
|
tmd,
Our highest graded senior class (4th kyu and up) is relativelly small, with only 8 or so active students. I don't think any of us feel they are held back, quite on the contrary. There is a general consensus that the gradings are supposed to be hard, and that the students should work hard to achieve their new rank. When the challenge is greater, the fruit of the labour is sweeter. In fact many of us have openly expressed disappointment and frustration towards changes in the curriculum, that would seemingly make things easier.
I myself have tried for 2nd kyu and failed, others have been denied grading altogether. Yes, it is disappointing, but we choose high standards over worthless pieces of cotton.
I'm not sure what to answer to the drop-out rate. One student quit last year when he was denied grading. A few others have quit after beeing promoted to 4th kyu, some of which admitted that they were not ready to meet the expectations that comes with practicing in the "black-belt class". All in all, I'd say the drop-out rate is roughly 30%, but people (also) quit for other reasons than beeing "held back", such as moving away, growing old, injuries, family, job etc..
I hope that answers your questions.
Osu!