Semi or Full contact?

Fighting is an integral part of nature. When not fighting for survival against predators, animals fight each other for dominance, power, and control. When fighting each other, the combat is usually ritual without deadly results. Humans are no different. We fight for survival against rogue humans and other animals and we also participate in ritual combat to determine the best warriors. One type of ritual combat is free-sparring as practiced by most martial arts. Free-sparring has evolved into two main types: no-contact/light-contact and full-contact.

No-contact sparring has its roots in the early Kung-fu systems dating back to sixth-century China, when Boddhidharma introduced his fighting techniques. As these methodologies spread throughout the Far East, other fighting styles developed. Although full-contact sparring claims an Eastern origin, it incorporates techniques found in Western-style boxing and is generally considered to be a more modern approach to sparing.

Hundreds of no-contact tournaments are conducted every year with competitors of all ages and genders. Full contact tournaments are not as popular and most competitors are adult men, although women and some children also compete.

No-contact competition emphasizes scoring with little or no contact. In point-sparring, engagement is stopped at the first score as with WKO rules, or continuous-sparring, points accumulate without stopping engagement as with Kyokushin Clicker tournaments. Speed and directness are stressed in no-contact sparring. Full-contact competition just gets started at the point where a no-contact engagement is stopped. Once they close the gap with a kick or a punch, full-contact fighters follow-up with close-range weapons such as elbows, knees, throws, joint locks, and grabbing techniques. Powerful, potentially lethal techniques are important in full-contact fighting so it uses more circular techniques, like hook kicks and hook punches. Although they are slower than the direct, linear techniques of no-contact sparring, they generate much more power. Since a knockout is the goal in full-contact sparring, head punches (kick-boxing) and head kicks are numerous. Full-contact sparring techniques are mostly close in and flow easily from one to another, where as, in no-contact sparring, techniques are fired from the farthest, safest distance possible, and at the first available moment. Since the emphasis in no-contact sparring is speed, straight-line techniques are preferred.

In no-contact sparring, you attack specific body targets with fully controlled techniques that do not make contact, but must appear to be powerful, thus pinpoint accuracy is necessary. Competitors train for speed and accuracy. Since matches last only two or three minutes, endurance is not a major concern. In full-contact sparring, since the goal is to knock out the opponent, techniques do not have to precise, only effective, so power is paramount. Full-contact competitors must use continual power, even when exhausted, so they train to increase endurance and stamina.

Since, no-contact competitors use straight-line techniques, they generally attack areas located along the centerline of the frontal portion of the body and head. Full-contact competitors attack the same areas, but, since they use more circular, hooking techniques, they also aim for the jaw, temples, and kidneys.

No-contact sparring is more traditional in its philosophy, history, and etiquette. Since religion plays an important role in the Eastern cultures, it affected the development of traditional martial art styles that use no-contact sparring. This may be why traditional no-contact fighters continue training longer on the average than full-contact practitioners. Traditional students learn how to integrate their style's philosophies into their everyday lives, and enjoy more efficient, harmonious life-styles. On the other hand, full-contact fighters have more of a "nomadic warrior" mentality. Since they spend so much time in intense and mostly solitary training, fighting and conditioning is all they think about. Like boxers, they usually have short careers. Since no-contact fighters have fewer injuries in training and in competition, they are able to compete longer and into older ages.

No-contact practitioners tend to only follow the generally accepted training methods of their particular style, which means they miss out on techniques that may be more suited to their body type. Since avoiding injury is a major concern, their techniques may not be effective against real attackers. Full contact fighters are usually taught a mixture of several fighting concepts and they continually experiment to discover what techniques work best for them. Because they have fought under actual combat conditions and absorbed punishment, they are better prepared for real attackers than no-contact fighters.

Both types of sparring have their place in the martial arts. As a potential martial arts student, you should choose an art and school within that art that has the level of contact that matches your goals.

Reference

Muzila, T. (2002). Traditional Karate -vs- Full Contact Karate.
My personal belief is that the best path to chose is your own, I know some knockdown fighters who are also incredible at all forms of Kihon including being Kata champions and also semi-contact champions – I know others that are great warriors on the mat but have never graded past the lower levels as it is the fighting they enjoy and not the art.


Clicker, or semi contact fighting does lend itself to being a more rounded martial artist, the intensity or training required is much less and easier to integrate with your normal classes. For my recent tournament I added around 10-15 hours a week of additional training to my normal classes, I have read that for international fighters it's more like 20-24 hours a week; that's a lot of time and commitment from both you and your family to your training and not something that can be sustained long term by many.


A great point made in the above article though draws your attention to the reality of fighting, of having techniques that work for you and an ability that goes beyond the mat or dojo, this is why I chose Kyokushin – it has everything I want from a martial art, high levels of expectancy from its students as practitioners of kihon as well as fighting ability and martial spirit.